Farina's Supper Club, nestled in the heart of Michigan City, is a gem in the Italian dining scene that promises an exceptional culinary experience. Patrons consistently rave about the cuisine, particularly delights like Nana's Gravy, fish specials, and the standout eggplant parmesan, which is celebrated for its cheesy goodness and rich sauce. The Scallop Risotto and lamb dishes have also garnered praise for their outstanding flavors, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to quality.
Service at Farina's is another highlight, with friendly and attentive staff like Victoria who make every dining experience memorable. Guests have shared heartfelt moments, celebrating anniversaries and special occasions, which speaks to the warm, inviting atmosphere of the establishment. While there have been minor concerns regarding an unpleasant odor reported by some, the overwhelmingly positive feedback about the food and service overshadows this issue.
Overall, Farina's Supper Club is highly recommended for anyone craving authentic Italian flavors and a lively ambience. For food lovers seeking a true taste of Italy in a cozy setting, this restaurant is definitely worth a visit.
Amenities and More
From the business
Identifies as women-owned
Service options
Outdoor seating
Kerbside pickup
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in
Highlights
Fireplace
Great cocktails
Great coffee
Great dessert
Great wine list
Sport
Popular for
Dinner
Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Food
Happy-hour drinks
Spirits
Vegetarian options
Wine
Dining options
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Romantic
Trendy
Upmarket
Crowd
Family friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists
Planning
Dinner reservations recommended
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
On-site parking
Pets
Dogs allowed
Dogs allowed outside
Photos
Reviews For Farina's Supper Club
Tamara Szarszewski
Jun 18,2025
We had a wonderful dinner here. We loved Nana's Gravy, and the server was excellent. I would highly recommend this place if you are in the area!
Lynn Jaynes
Jun 14,2025
Our Daughter took us for our 51st wedding Anniversary and Father’s Day Lunch from start to finish the service and Food is a 5 star plus. We had 2 Fish Specials Sea Bass and White Fish both phenomenal and my wife had white clam sauce linguini We will be back. Lovely day!
JudiSomer Art
May 18,2025
We celebrated our Anniversary here last night and always have a delicious meal. Last night the lamb was exceptional and Scallop Risotto outstanding, eggplant stack salad very good and we took home Cannoli Cake which was perfection. Victoria always serves us with a smile. Tj & Judi Somer
david black
Apr 17,2025
Food and service are absolutely top-notch! I gave it a five star, but I must say the one thing that we did not like was this horrible septic smell and that is something that they need to work on but other than that, we absolutely think this place is wonderful!
Mizz SheLLz
Apr 17,2025
This was my first time to eat at this restaurant tucked in a small community to celebrate my birthday! The eggplant parmesan was so cheesy and it was so good, especially the sauce it was bathed in which came with a side of your choice of pasta. When it came to dessert I chose the Tiramisu which was so good not too sweet and served with sliced strawberries. Overall, I would recommend this establishment to anyone who loves authentic Italian dishes. I will be coming to this place more often!!!
Margaret O'Donnell
Apr 13,2025
This place is a one of a kind treasure! It's set in a beautiful beach side neighborhood and is quite romantic yet lively for family and friends. There is an incredible cozy pub off the lobby (it was an inn at one point) and then the large restaurant is spread throughout a few grand rooms/spaces throughout 1 level which makes the entire atmosphere more intimate and interesting. In the summertime, there is a wonderful stone patio set within the trees which adds to the atmosphere. The food is amazing! We always order wine because they carry so many authentic wines I can't find anywhere around here. I love their bread but always need to be sure to save room for dinner. We sampled several of the delicious appetizers family-style between the group (the calamari is a must and we had the famous meatballs) then moved on to some incredible entrees. My lamb chops were so tender and the portion was so big that I was able to enjoy them for lunch the next day! We were stuffed by the end of the meal but have learned to take home a dessert to share for later because they are THAT good. I love this place and am so glad it is so close to home. It's like Chicago (or Italy) are in my backyard!
Pat Parker
Apr 8,2025
Fabulous dining experiences every time! We especially enjoy their fish dishes and cocktails. Best marinara and bread too!
Tara LaRose
Mar 27,2025
Food was phenomenal, staff was phenomenal! Shout out to our sweet waitress, Kendra! Tucked back in a nice wooded neighborhood. Highly recommend!
Reviews For Farina's Supper Club